ClubsNSW whistleblower reveals the ‘alarming’ scale of money laundering in pokies rooms at local clubs and pubs
ABC Investigations By Steve Cannane,Kyle Taylor and Clare Blumer
Updated Thursday 13 February 2020
PHOTO: It’s estimated that fewer than 10 per cent of clubs are compliant with anti-money laundering and financing of terrorism laws.
A whistleblower and former employee of ClubsNSW has claimed that money laundering through poker machines is rife in pubs and clubs across the country.
- A ClubsNSW board document obtained by the ABC shows up to 95 per cent of clubs have not been complying with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism finance laws
- Independent MP Andrew Wilkie said in Parliament that the clubs were “operating illegally”
- ClubsNSW says it is helping smaller clubs to meet the requirements, while larger clubs are being “proactive”
In an exclusive interview with the ABC, Troy Stolz, a former ClubsNSW anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism finance (AML/CTF) compliance auditor, said that the scale of the problem was both “massive” and “alarming”.
“The crooks are going [into pubs and clubs] with their drug money and putting it in the machines and the crooks are cleaning it,” he said.
In a speech to Federal Parliament earlier today, independent MP Andrew Wilkie said up to95 per cent of clubs in New South Wales were “operating illegally” by not complying with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing laws.
“No-one is doing anything about it,” he said.
Mr Wilkie said the “alarming information” came from a 2019 ClubsNSW board paper provided to him by a whistleblower.
Mr Wilkie requested leave to table the ClubsNSW board document in Parliament, but leave was not granted.
“Deputy Speaker … they’re running a protection racket for the gambling industry,” he called out after the decision.
Mr Stolz, who worked for ClubsNSW for nine years and left his job in September last year, told the ABC he was the source of the leaked document.
ClubsNSW represents over 1,000 RSL, sporting and other clubs in the state, which has around half of Australia’s poker machines.
A ClubsNSW spokesperson described today’s speech as “more anti-club hysteria from Andrew Wilkie”.
“If Andrew Wilkie has evidence of a licensed venue not meeting its AML/CTF obligations then he should raise the matter with AUSTRAC so the regulator can properly investigate,” the spokesperson said.
Space to play or pause, M to mute, left and right arrows to seek, up and down arrows for volume.VIDEO: Andrew Wilkie says up to 95 per cent of big gambling clubs are not policing money laundering. (ABC News)
How criminals launder money using the pokies
The poker machine industry is one of the sectors of the economy most vulnerable to organised crime.
Neil Jeans, an independent consultant in anti-money laundering compliance, has previously estimated that around $65-75 billion worth of cash goes through the pokies across Australia each year.PHOTO: Troy Stolz worked for ClubsNSW for nine years. (ABC News: Troy Stolz)
Mr Stolz explained how low and mid-tier drug operations were exploiting club pokies rooms, by depositing large sums of cash into poker machines, playing for a short period of time, then withdrawing the laundered money.
“With criminal organisations or individuals exploiting clubs and pubs … they’re willing to lose 20-30 per cent of what they want to clean at the end of the day to get that winning cheque or that piece of paper that validates where they’ve got that money from,” he said.
An estimated 770 clubs in NSW have more than 15 poker machines and are therefore considered “full reporting entities” under the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act.
These clubs are required to make reports for transactions over $10,000 to the regulator AUSTRAC.
Gambling: Tell us your story
ABC Investigations wants your help to find out more about what happens behind the scenes of Australia’s gambling industry; to hear from people who have worked inside the industry and those who have lost money. Fill out our tips form here.
Mr Stolz said that most launderers worked just below the threshold for what might raise suspicions for large transactions.
“These criminals know that the limit is $10,000. So they will structure their transactions to go under the radar so they might go in and do say $5,500, take part cheque, part cash,” he said.
Mr Stolz said it can be labour intensive to launder money in this way but that clubs are ‘untouched’ by authorities compared to the banks.
“To clean the money from your drug sales, you send out someone — a uni student — working for you, in a day and give them 50 or 100 different venues to do. And you’ve got a team of 10. It’s quite easy to clean a lot of that money,” he said.
‘The whole industry is at risk’
Part of Mr Stolz’s former job involved advising and training staff from member clubs on what the law required them to do to prevent money-laundering, particularly around poker machines.
He said the understanding of these issues at the individual club level was “still very primitive”.
“The whole industry is at risk,” he said.
“The gaming machines are a perfect opportunity for launderers to get into venues — you’re relying on staff to be diligent, trained and the systems [to be] in place to pick up any abnormal behaviour.”
ClubsNSW should ‘enhance’ training, board paper says
The internal ClubsNSW document recommended that the association should “enhance” its training to member clubs in this area.
Clubs that pay around $30,000 per year for what’s called ClubSAFE premium membership get the top training package included with its membership.
Smaller clubs that could not afford premium membership get minimal training and must pay for additional training courses.
While ClubsNSW enjoys the benefits of not-for-profit status, the board paper quoted by Mr Wilkie refers to the importance of ClubsNSW making a profit out of its services — such as anti-money laundering training — that the organisation provides to member clubs.
“The most fundamental challenge is balancing the need to support members through the delivery of efficient and effective services while also generating a profit to contribute to the financial imperatives of ClubsNSW,” the document said.INFOGRAPHIC: An excerpt from page 1 of notes to ClubNSW board members before a meeting in 2019. (Supplied)
A ClubsNSW spokesperson said they had identified the challenges for “low-risk” smaller clubs “given that many of these venues are community-run operations with a small number of paid staff”.
Moreover, ClubsNSW said its larger member clubs were taking a “proactive approach … and had appropriately minimised their risk of falling victim to money laundering practices”.
“ClubsNSW takes this issue very seriously, as do our members, with thousands of club employees completing AML/CTF training in the past 18 months alone.”
Regulator could do more
The Federal Government’s financial intelligence agency, AUSTRAC, is responsible for monitoring venues to make sure programs are in place which monitor transactions or identify customers.
Mr Stolz says that in 2016 he was told by AUSTRAC that 150 pubs and clubs had been ‘red flagged’ because they weren’t compliant, but in the last five years, no club had been issued a fine.
Do you know more?
Please fill out the ABC Investigations gambling story tips form, or text message the team via the WhatsApp or Signal mobile apps on 0418 347 462.
Mr Stolz said AUSTRAC was not doing enough to enforce compliance in pubs and clubs.
“AUSTRAC essentially can come and pull the plug on your gaming machines”, he said.
“If we want to get down [on] crime and improve community standards, we should be addressing this issue. And it’s not hard at all. Governments should throw a little bit of money into AUSTRAC, give them some extra bodies and let them loose on the industry.”
A spokesperson from AUSTRAC said it assessed the compliance of several pubs and clubs in NSW in 2019.
“AUSTRAC engages closely with pubs and clubs and industry associations, including ClubsNSW, to help educate staff working in pubs and clubs so they know what to look out for,” the spokesperson said.
Mr Stolz is currently involved in a legal dispute with ClubsNSW, his former employer.
ClubsNSW did not comment on questions relating to Mr Stolz.
Share your gambling story with us
We know gambling is a widespread national issue affecting millions of Australians.
So, we want your help to find out more about what happens behind the scenes of Australia’s gambling industry; to hear from people who have worked inside the industry and those who have lost money.
We assure you that any information you give us will be treated as strictly confidential. We won’t publish anything you tell us, or identify you, without getting your permission.
The ABC is using the Screendoor tool to collect your story tips. The ABC’s Collection Statement applies to any information you provide. *Name *Email *Phone numberIf you are sending confidential information, please contact us using Signal or WhatsApp on 0418 347 462. Please don’t send us information via a normal text message as it will not be secure, nor encrypted.
If you need the highest level of security and anonymisation, please use SecureDrop: https://www.abc.net.au/news/secure-drop/.Would you like to receive email updates about this investigation?Would you like to receive email updates about this investigation? * Yes NoWhat is your involvement with the gambling industry?What is your involvement with the gambling industry? * I have worked in the gambling industry (e.g. pubs, clubs, casinos, sport betting agencies, gaming companies) I have worked in a gambling-related field (e.g. lobbying, politics, sports, marketing, counselling, outreach) I have gambled I have a friend or relative who has gambled OtherDo you think responsible gambling is taken seriously inside the industry?Do you think responsible gambling is taken seriously inside the industry? Yes NoDo you have anything else you would like to tell us about the gambling industry?Do you have any photos, video or documents you are happy to provide us?Do you have any photos, video or documents you are happy to provide us? * Yes NoIf you’re a member of clubs that profit from gambling, please list them here.Which part of the gambling industry have you told us the most about today?Which part of the gambling industry have you told us the most about today? * Sports betting Pubs and clubs Poker machines Casinos Racing Lotteries Advertising, marketing and media OtherWhich state or territory have you been telling us about? * Choose an option ACT NSW NT QLD SA TAS VIC WA What’s your postcode? *SavedSubmitPowered byScreendoor.